Puzzle: 11 consecutive instances of ‘had’

My first English teacher at secondary school said that a perfectly valid text can contain 11 consecutive instances of ‘had’: had had had had had had had had had had had

All it needs is some punctuation.

Can you see how to do it? I will give a hint on 7 May and another hint on 14 May. I’ll post the answer on 21 May.

If you don’t want to miss the hints or the answer, you can sign up to alerts from the home page or from the contact page.


  1. No answer from me yet, but I am fascinated to think about this one. The best I managed as a youth was (on the subject of sea voyages)”The biscuits they had had had had to be dried for an extended period of time”. My history teacher was not impressed.

  2. I remember this from my own schooldays, so I won’t give it away – but it’s a genuine answer and not at all contrived (well, hardly)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *