Talking with ET

Who knew that a word exists to describe the study of extraterrestrial language? The word—Xenolinguistics—features in the title of a recent book Xenolinguistics: towards a Science of Extraterrestrial Language (2024), edited by Douglas A Vakoch and Jeffrey Punske.

In the book, biologists, anthropologists, linguists, and specialists in communication explore what is known about human language and animal communication systems, and discuss how communication by and with extra-terrestrials might work.

Throughout this post, I use alien as shorthand for extra-terrestrial life.

Overview

Chapter 1 Goals of the volume is a brief introduction by co-editor Jeffrey Prunske. He says that the book explores what we know about animal communication systems, human language and linguistics, communication systems more generally and other cognitive systems on Earth. The goal is to provide reasonable hypotheses about what we may find if we meet aliens that have language capabilities. 

In this post, I look at the next 8 chapters (in a sequence differing from the book). They discuss the following topics, analysing possible implications for communication between humans and aliens.

  • how animals communicate on Earth
  • how animals and pre-verbal human children know when someone is talking to them—and then decode the meaning
  • using behaviour by aliens to decode their language
  • how animals communicate with other animals and with humans
  • how animals communicate with other animals and with humans (2)
  • learning to communicate between cultures
  • the non-verbal part of communication
  • how language has co-evolved with cultures, societies and technology

In a future post, I will discuss the other 9 chapters (10-18).

How animals communicate on Earth

In Chapter 2 Many Ways to Say Things: What the Diversity of Animal Communication on Earth Can Tell Us About the Likely Nature of Alien Language, Arik Kershenbaum discusses:

  • communication modalities; and
  • encoding mechanisms.

Kershenbaum looks not only at the advantages and disadvantages of various communication modalities and encoding mechanisms. He also considers whether there would be sufficient selective pressure to make it plausible that they could develop through evolution.

Communication modalities

Kershenbaum notes that the communication modalities most widely used by humans and other animals on Earth are acoustic and visual. Acoustic signals:

  • move fast—340 metres per second in air and 1,500 m/s in water.
  • can carry much more information than slowly varying modalities such as olfactory clues (smells and scents).
  • can be generated with varying frequency, varying amplitude and varying ‘formants’ (harmonic frequencies). These variations can encode a great deal of information.
  • diffract around objects often found on land and in water. So, the receiver can detect them even if the sender is outside the receiver’s line of sight.
  • travel well only in dense gases or in rarefied liquids.

Visual signals can carry large amounts of information, but:

  • can be obscured by solid objects or scattered by atmospheric particles.
  • are more difficult to distinguish at long ranges than acoustic signals because decoding visual signals depends on angular resolution.
  • their frequency cannot be measured directly (as we do with sounds). Instead, different colours are distinguished by arbitrary filters, although light of different frequencies can be combined.

Kershenbaum discusses 3 other conceivable communication modalities, concluding that their disadvantages make it unlikely that aliens would use them:

  • chemical sensing and olfaction. Animals on earth do use simple chemical signals (eg pheromones). But chemical signals move slowly, which makes them unsuited for two-way communication, especially over long distances. In addition, because chemical signals do not fade rapidly, they do not readily form linear sequences of discrete signals. Also, it is difficult to detect where olfactory signs come from, particularly if they diffuse through a turbulent fluid.
  • electrical signals. Some electric fish and some other animals use electric currents to convey information such as species, individual, identity, sex and social status. But the typical range of electrical signals on Earth A is less than 1 metre. That is because their strength drops off more rapidly (with the cube of the distance) than the strength of a visual or acoustic signal (with the square of the distance). A longer range would be possible if the recipient had an array of electrical receptors, each tuned to a separate frequency. But Kershenbaum doubts whether there could be sufficient selective pressure for such an array to arise through natural selection.
  • magnetic signals.  Although some animals have developed magnetic sensing, no animals on earth communicate with magnetic signals. Magnetic communication is unlikely to evolve. Where background magnetic fields are strong (like on Earth), local magnetic fields would swamp any magnetic signals. And where there are no strong magnetic fields, organisms would face no strong selective pressure to develop an ability to sense magnetic fields.    

Kershenbaum discuses only communication between organisms located in the same place. For inter-stellar communication, I presume there is only remotely viable option: for both humans and aliens to transcode their native languages into electro-magnetic waves.

Encoding mechanisms

Kershenbaum notes that one feature of human language is what the linguist Charles Hockett called ‘duality of patterning’. There is a large number of units of meaning (words or morphemes), but these are made up of arrangements of a few distinguishable sounds drawn from a small stock and having no intrinsic meaning. Hockett illustrated this duality of patterning with the English words tack, cat and act. They are totally distinct in meaning, yet are composed of just the same 3 basic meaningless sounds in different permutations.

I found a perhaps clearer description of Hockett’s ‘duality of patterning’ in the book Parameter Hierarchies & Universal Grammar (2019) by Ian Roberts, one of the authors of chapter 15 of this book. Roberts describes duality of patterning as ‘meaningless phonemes combine to form meaningful morphemes and morphemes combine further into words and sentences’.

Although humans communicate using discrete and distinct packages of information, many species appear to communicate using non-discrete continuously variable signals. Examples include jumping spiders and kangaroo rates, bottlenose dolphins and wolves. Thus, Kershenbaum suggests we might find aliens using either discrete signals or continuously variable signals.

I’m not sure whether referring to Hockett’s ‘duality of patterning’ is the clearest way for Kershenbaum to make his point. That point seems to be more about the distinction between analogue and digital signals, and less about combining a small stock of distinguishable (but meaningless) sounds into many meaningful words.  

How animals and pre-verbal human children know when someone is talking to them—and then decode the meaning

Chapter 3 Recognizing Intentional Signals and Their Meaning in Non-Human Communication is by Catherine Hobaiter, Adriano R Lameira and Derek Ball. They suggest that we can use a Gricean framework to tell whether someone is trying to talk to us and what they are trying to tell us. The Gricean approach assumes that partners in conversation work together to share meaning. They do that by producing signals with the intention that the addressee(s) will form a belief by recognising that intention.  For more on Grice, please see What you say and what you mean – Language Miscellany

The authors point out that Gricean tools have been used in studying communication by animals and pre-verbal human children. So, they might be usable in analysing how we could communicate with aliens.

Hobaiter and her co-authors suggest that there are 2 steps:

  • 1st step—detecting that the other party intends to transmit information.
  • 2nd step—decoding what the other party means.

Step 1 detecting intention

We might detect:

  • interstellar communications between aliens and other aliens. Detecting the fact that these communications are intentional may be difficult. That is because we may well not be able to see how the parties interact with each other and how that interaction shapes their subsequent communication.
  • interstellar communications from aliens directed to other species unknown to them (such as humans). Detecting that these communications are intentional may not be as difficult. A common solution found in nature is to bounce back an exact copy of the message several times, before starting to vary it.

Step 2 decoding meaning

Hobaiter and her co-authors suggest that decoding what aliens mean will be much more difficult than detecting that aliens intend to transit meaning (though still not impossible). This is because:

  • to establish what the signaller means, we need to observe the behaviour by the recipient that makes the signaller decide to stop signalling, to persist with signalling or to elaborate the signal. Observing the behaviour may be challenging over inter-stellar distances.
  • decoding meaning requires hundreds if not thousands of exemplars. It will take a long time to gather so many examples because signals will not return for many years, centuries or even longer.
  • to interpret what a signal means, both signaller and receiver rely on presuppositions about the underlying physical and social context. In trying to decode ancient human languages, humans share at least some basic presuppositions about the terrestrial environment and about human behaviour, aims and desires. But we may not share even basic presuppositions of this kind with aliens.
  • standard applications of the Gricean toolkit work only in cases that require a consistent behavioural response.

Cracking unknown codes and unknown languages usually starts with breaking a single item whose possible meaning is given by context. To make even the next few steps possible, we may need to start by using simple signals with simple messages.

Hobaiter and her co-authors think that the task, though difficult, may not be hopeless. If there is evidence of an intention to communicate, an exchange of signals already permits some presuppositions—for example, that the parties are capable of communication in which we may be able to discern their intentions. Although the Gricean toolkit does not provide a simple recipe for understanding Xenolanguage, it might point to fruitful directions for further inquiry.

Using behaviour by aliens to decode their language

In Chapter 9 Why Do We Assume That We Can Decode Alien Languages? Con Slobodchikoff suggests we should not be optimistic that we will be able to decode signals we may receive from Aliens. We have not yet decoded:

  • some ancient writing systems used by humans, including linear A from the Minoan culture of around 1500 BCE, Vinča symbols from around 5000BCE, Rongorongo from Easter Island and Olmec from around 1200 BCE.
  • most communication systems used by non-human animals on Earth.

Slobodchikoff points out that it only became possible to decode Egyptian hieroglyphs once archaeologists found the Rosetta Stone. This stone contains the same text in 3 languages: ancient Greek, demotic Egyptian and Egyptian hieroglyphs. For more on Hieroglyphs and the Rosetta Stone, please see Hieroglyphs: unlocking ancient Egypt – Language Miscellany

Slobodchikoff suggests that without something like a Rosetta stone, we may not be able to decode ancient human languages, non-human animal communication on Earth or extra-terrestrial communication systems. He says that his own research on prairie dogs has made some progress in decoding their communication. He has done this using the ‘Rosetta Stone’ of observations of (and recordings of) prairie dogs’ behaviour and alarm calls. Prairie dogs are ground squirrels living in extensive burrow systems (‘town’ or ‘colonies’).

Design features of human language

Like several other chapters in this book, this chapter refers to a list of 13 design features of human language, produced in 1960 by the linguist Charles Hockett. Slobodchikoff says that 7 of them are key features distinguishing human language from ‘mere communication’. Table 1 lists those 7 features and summarises their presence in prairie dog communication.

Design feature (per Hockett)Prairie dogs (per Slobodchikoff)
1. Semantic. Each signal (or word) has a distinct meaning.Prairie dogs have distinctly different alarm calls for different species of predator (coyotes, domestic dogs, red-tailed hawks, humans). Also, the acoustic elements within the alarm call for a predator species vary by the predator’s size, colour and shape.
2. Arbitrary. The meaning of a word does not determine its form (with some possible partial exceptions, such as onomatopoeia).Alarm calls are arbitrary.
3. Discrete. Each signal must be a distinct unit (just as each word in a sentence is a distinct unit).Each alarm call is a discrete unit.
4. Displacement. A language can provide information about events occurring in a location different from the speaker, or at a different time.Alarm calls can refer to a predator that is far away.
5. Productivity.  A language can make up new words.Prairie dogs can coin new calls for objects they have never seen before, such as a black oval, a triangle or a circle.
6. Duality. A language has smaller units that can combine into larger units. For instance, phonemes can combine into morphemes and words can combine into sentences.Alarm calls are made up of phonemes, in different proportions for different species of predator.
7. Cultural transmission. We are not born knowing a language; we acquire it.New-born prairie dogs have a generic call for all predators (apparently under genetic control). Later, their calls acquire most specific components (by cultural transmission). 
Table 1. Seven design features distinguishing human language from ‘mere communication’.

For reference, table 2 lists Hockett’s other 6 design features.

8. Vocal-auditory channel. Rather than other channels, such as gesture, dancing by bees or courtship rituals of stickleback fish.
9. Rapid fading. Vocal signals do not linger for reception at the hearer’s convenience. Written records do persist, but they are only a product of recent cultural evolution.
10. Broadcast transmission and directional transmission. A linguistic signal can be heard by any auditory system within earshot. And the hearer can localise the source by binaural direction-finding.
11. Interchangeability. Speakers can reproduce any linguistic message they can understand. In contrast, for example, male and female sticklebacks cannot act out courtship motions of the other sex.
12. Total feedback. Speakers hear everything they themselves say. In contrast, male sticklebacks cannot see the colours of their own eyes and belly that stimulate the female.
13. Specialization. The only function of bodily effort put into speech and the resulting sound waves is to serve as signals. In contrast, the panting of a dog may transmit information, but only as a side effect of the dog controlling its own temperature.
Table 2. Hockett’s other 6 design features of human language.
Renumbered as 8-13, instead of 1-6

Hockett describes his design features in Hockett, Charles F. (1960) The Origin of Speech, Scientific American 203, 88–111,  Reprinted in: Wang, William S-Y. (1982) Human Communication: Language and Its Psychobiological Bases, Scientific American pp. 4–12 https://web.stanford.edu/class/linguist197a/hockett60sciam.pdf

How animals communicate with other animals and with humans

IChapter 6 How Studies of Communication among Nonhumans and between Humans and Nonhumans Can Inform SETI is by Irene M Pepperberg. She reviews what we are beginning to understand about some non-human communication systems on Earth. She says we might use that knowledge to understand alien communication systems. She also suggests how we might go about trying to establish 2-way communication systems with aliens.

Systems studied so far include birdsong, vervet and prairie dog alarm calls, chimpanzee vocalizations and dolphin whistles.

Birds have some of the most complicated systems because, unlike nonhuman primates, some songbirds (known as ocsines) are vocal learners—their communications are not specified innately but are learned from older competent members of the species. Birds may have a song repertoire consisting of only one song or of thousands. Songs convey meanings in ways that differ between species. Some other songbirds (suboscines) do not learn their vocalisations, but do vary their songs to convey various meanings.

Other points

Some other points Pepperberg makes are:

  • we cannot assume that alien language will use sound or that sounds will be at frequencies that humans can hear. Some avian signals are visual (eg the flash of a redwing’s epaulets). And some birdsong (eg hummingbird vocalisations) occurs at the very limits of human auditory thresholds. That is also the case for bats, cetaceans and elephants.
  • signals are likely to be repetitive. In some cases, what conveys meaning is the number of repetitions, rather than individual meanings. For example, in black-capped chickadee alarm calls, the number of ‘dee’ syllables indicates the extent and severity of the threat. Swamp sparrow songs consist mainly of 3-note syllables, but the order of the syllables specifies where the singer lives. Similarly, in alien broadcasts, different patterns of similar signals might convey different meanings.
  • humans can miss meaning in the fine structure of animal signals, and there is a risk that we could similarly fail to detect meaning in alien signals. For example, some bird song seems to consist of simple signals but shows more complex patterns when played at reduced speeds.
  • sometimes, context is more important than the particular vocal pattern used. For example, song sparrows have repertoires of about 6 songs, used mainly to defend territory. The songs do not have different meanings. Instead, the song selected depends on the song sung by a neighbour and by the neighbour’s location. We may fail to understand alien signals if we do not have enough information about the context.  

Pepperberg describes in some detail how she has trained grey parrots to communicate (to some extent) with humans. She suggests that such procedures might provide insights into how we might establish 2-way communication with aliens.

Pepperberg’s conclusion

Pepperberg concludes that:

  • organisms do not need all the elements of human language to establish some level of communication within a specifies or between different species.
  • some communication systems have aspects completely foreign to humans.

How animals communicate with other animals and with humans (2)

Chapter 4 Getting Out of Our Skin: What Decoding Interspecies Communication and Nonhuman Intelligence Can Tell Us About Deciphering Alien Languages is by Denise L Herzing. She suggests that studying communication between different species on Earth might give us some insights into how humans might communicate with aliens. She comments that:

  • lab experiments have shown that many animals—including dolphins, chimpanzees and bonobos, and African Grey parrots—can understand syntax (syntax), word meaning (semantics) and abstract thought, and show self-awareness.
  • it is still unknown whether nonhuman animals use graded or referential systems of communication. It seems likely that most non-human animals use graded systems, but a few may use referential systems (eg dolphin signature whistles, vervet monkey alarm calls, ground squirrels, prairie dogs).
    She doesn’t say what she means by graded and referential. I suspect they might be similar to what Kershenbaum calls continuously variable signals and discrete signals (or, as I have said above, analogue and digital).
  • researchers have successfully created shared systems of communications with bonobo chimpanzees, African Grey Parrots and (to a more limited degree) dolphins.
  • many species have learnt to interpret signals from other species, or have developed new communication repertoires to transmit information to other species. Examples of interactions include those between different species of Dolphin and of other cetaceans and between dogs and humans.
  • communication between species can involve passive decoding or active interaction.
  • prosodic features (eg frequency, duration, amplitude, rhythm, synchronicity) need to be captured and analysed.
  • metadata (eg age, sex, relationship, life history) play an important role in interpreting communication signals. Information about the sensory system, cultures and social systems of a species enhances interpretation—but such information about aliens is likely to be unavailable or unrecognisable.
  • the approach known as ‘distributed cognition’ may lead to a more complete understanding of communication signals and their meaning.  Exchanges between individuals of measurable behaviours can be recorded and measured. Those measurements can be assessed more easily than mental states and intentions.

Learning to communicate between cultures

In Chapter 8 Interstellar Competence: Applications of Linguistics and Communicative and Cultural Competencies to Extraterrestrial Communication, Sumayya K.R. Granger, Judd Ethan Ruggill, and Ken S. McAllister discuss how humans from different cultural backgrounds learn to communicate with each other. Drawing on their experience as ‘specialists in intercultural competence and transdisciplinary communication and translation’ they suggest how we should approach learning how to communicate with extra-terrestrials.

Aliens will differ from humans in cognitive functions much more than humans differ from other humans. So, Granger and co-authors point out that communication between humans and with aliens will be even more difficult than communications between humans from different backgrounds. They suggest that:

  • we will initially know almost nothing about our alien conversation partners. Nevertheless, we can reasonably assume that all parties (human and non-human) sending and receiving interstellar messages will share 5 features: tool use; symbol use; communication; culture-making and curiosity. We will be able to build initially on that knowledge.
  • there are 3 stages in initiating intercultural exchanges: establishing contact; knowing that contact has occurred; and maintaining contact.
  • it has been more than 50 years since humans first sent deliberate messages into space—the MIR, LENIN, SSSR messages sent to Venus in Morse code. There has not yet been a recognisable reply to such messages, nor have we detected any inbound messages.
  • the nearest possibly habitable planets are many light years away. So, any inter-stellar conversation will be protracted and ‘hyper-asynchronous’—involving long gaps with turns in any conversation being many decades, centuries or millennia apart.
  • most likely, aliens receiving our initial outbound communications will focus first on the tool of message transmission itself: ‘What is this signal anomaly and how do we make sense of it?’

Initial strategy

The authors suggest the following strategy:

  • Medium. We should use a range of communication media, such as visible light, light invisible to humans, sound waves and physical objects to be touched, looked at or listened to.
  • Message robustness. Our signals should focus (initially) on information already familiar to the recipient (such as information about their star system, rather than information about us (for example, information our Solar System). Such signals would stand out against background noise, would show that we have this information and would provide a template for an understandable reply.
  • Error correction. At every stage of the process, there must be a vigorous effort to detect—and correct—errors of translation, interpretation and cordiality.
  • Mutual intelligibility. Intercultural exchange is always about trying to solve 2 problems at once:
    (a) What do they mean?
    (b) How can we help them to understand what we mean?

Strategy for later stages

Once communication starts to develop, Granger and her co-authors suggest:

  • gradually introducing more complex ideas. One specific proposal is to send what they call Associated Information Packets (AIP)—physical containers holding objects as well as messages. An example might be an AIP about carbon, containing (a piece of graphite; (b) a diamond; (c) diagrams showing the structure and atomic weight of both substances; (d) information about their weight on earth and their mass.
  • developing a list of core vocabulary, proceeding slowly and patiently in a way that avoids introducing human bias, and does not rush towards trying to create full language. Granger and co-authors warn that communication may well plateau for a long time, perhaps even indefinitely. They caution that we might not be able to reach a level of fluency above level A1 in the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages developed by the Council of Europe.
  • finding a way to tell aliens, perhaps using a finite set of parameters, in what ways human cultures differ from each other. The authors suggest that Optimality Theory (developed originally for phonological analysis) could provide one way to do this. Optimality Theory assumes that there is a set of parameters (constraints) that are universal, but whose ranking varies from language to language. An outcome that breaks a constraint is used only if: (a) that outcome meets all higher-ranking constraints; and (b) no other available outcome meets both that constraint and all higher-ranking constraints.
  • Even small socio-cultural differences can have a dramatic effect on how relations develop or do not develop. So, initial communication should be neutral, focusing on factual observations about interstellar space until communication pathways are robust enough to handle the discovery and processing of more emotionally-charged expressions of meaning. And it would be unwise to share information about life on Earth indiscriminately.

The non-verbal part of communication

In chapter 5 Communicative Resources Beyond the Verbal Tier: A View on Xenolinguistics from Interactional Linguistics, Heike Ortner reflects on how our own bodily form affects everyday interactions. She starts with 2 cases when humans lack most of the bodily functions that most people use in communication. One case is a patient with global aphasia and the other is a patient with locked-in syndrome. Both patients manage some communication (albeit limited) with their carers.

Ortner discusses only direct face-to-face interaction. She does not deal with face-to-face interaction mediated through technology (eg a screen) or through abstract symbols only with no direct perception of the other party.

Interactional linguistics

Ortner draws from interactional linguistics—a relatively new research program on ‘meaning-making with all available resources in face-to-face interaction: verbal utterances, voice, gaze, body postures and body orientation, positioning in space, facial expression, object manipulation, gesture and other body movements, or generally any kind of action’. Ortner points out that many resources could be central to how aliens interact: touch, colour, scents and so on.

Role of culture

Ortner stresses that multimodal signs are not universal, but learned and culturally diverse. This means we may have little hope of understanding bodily expressions (like gesture or facial expression) by aliens even if their outer morphology is similar to ours.

She says that language:

  • is a dynamic process, not a static entity;
  • is physically embodied and publicly displayed;
  • delivers actions;
  • organises its resources as paradigmatic alternatives for specific positions in the syntagms of turns and sequences;
  • is temporally remergent, allowing for projection, extension and repair; and
  • is shared and continuously provides for co-participation.

Interactions typically flow in the following sequence, but we might need to find a different flow in communicating with aliens whose concepts of time and space may differ greatly from ours:

  1. first, a participant produces an action (an ‘action-be-understood’);
  2. then the recipient displays their understanding of the action;
  3. then the producer acknowledges that understanding.

Ortner points out that when we interact with animals, we often interpret their signals using our experience as humans, but she cautions against assuming that the animal has a mind.  

Building common ground and rapport

Meaning ‘unfolds only in the context of an embodied contextual configuration’, building in prior international histories and on both shared and private experiences’. So, we are led at first by assumptions and expectations regarding other participants, but we can quickly establish common ground moulded by our interactive negotiations.

Ortner suggests that a good starting point in building rapport with aliens would be to use behavioural mimicry (automatic imitation of gestures, postures, mannerisms and other motor movements). Once we have begun to establish a common ‘language’, we can then start to use more complex strategies, adjusting our communication to either diminish or enhance social and communicative differences between the aliens and ourselves. This can be done by verbal gestures or by interactive displays (eg smiling, nodding or other gestures). Further strategies are recipient design (orientation towards co-participants) and audience design (linguistic devices to seek the approval of the audience).

Main challenges

The main challenges we would face in communicating with aliens include:

  • recognising relevant interactional displays (and even systems of displays) as cues and codes for understanding;
  • finding some common ground, or a starting point for inter-subjectivity;
  • getting a grasp on how aliens conceive of time and space;
  • making ourselves comprehensible, not taking our own bodily design for granted and trying to think from the perspective of a different body.
  • giving cues on how to disassemble our own signals into units.
  • developing strategies to complete communicative tasks such as initiating repair strategies for when communication breaks down.

How language has co-evolved with cultures, societies and technology

Chapter 7 Patterns of Communication of Human Complex Societies as a Blueprint for Alien Communication is by Anamaria Berea. She argues that the ways humans communicate today started local and then recently became global, co-evolving with languages, cultures, societies and technologically inclined civilization.  She speculates that statistical regularities of social and collective phenomena may:

  • show us features specific to the evolution of language; and
  • help us understand better what we might expect from alien language.

Berea suggests that other intelligent beings wishing to make contact will have both technology and language based on technology. She says that current technologies are on track to give us deeper understanding of universals in technology-based communication and universal laws of information theory. At the same time, we need to understand what is just parochial, rather than universal. This will help us narrow down the framework for xenolinguistics.

Comments

It seems very unlikely that aliens will happen to visit Earth in the next few thousand years. And we certainly won’t reach other stars in that time. So, for the foreseeable future, any contact between humans and aliens will probably be through radio signals or other electro-magnetic signals sent by humans or aliens over inter-stellar distances.

Obstacles

Any inter-stellar communication between humans and aliens will face formidable obstacles:

  • aliens’ conceptual structures, thinking patterns and languages may differ considerably from ours, perhaps in ways that we cannot even imagine;
  • any conversation will be extremely protracted. There will be gaps of perhaps many centuries or longer between each turn in a conversation (eg a statement or question) and its response.
  • human language and other communication on Earth depends heavily on context and also on learning how to use context to convey information effectively and to decode messages. We won’t be able to observe aliens’ behaviour and the context in which they  transmit messages—and they won’t be able to observe our behaviour and the context for our messages. Without such observations, both aliens and humans may find it difficult (or even impossible) to learn how to decode each others’ native languages.
  • if aliens receive human speech (or human writing) broadcast as, for example, radio waves, they would face 2 daunting problems:
    (a) decoding the speech (or writing) from the radio waves; and
    (b) unravelling the meaning of the speech (or writing).
    Alien broadcasts would present similar problems to us.
  • there will not be some Rosetta Stone giving us the first vital clue to decoding alien language.

Overcoming the obstacles

The chapters discussed above point to how we might try to overcome some of the above obstacles:

  • initial stages of our messages should focus—probably for many thousands of years— on conveying our intention to communicate, not on trying to communicate anything specific. Observing both behaviour and context is a necessary supporting scaffolding for building a vocabulary, syntax and semantics. Without that scaffolding, working out how to pass on significant amounts of information will be exceptionally challenging.
  • we should not design our initial messages to pass on information about ourselves. Without observing us and our context, aliens will lack the Rosetta Stone needed to crack our signals. Instead, we should design our messages to be decodable by beings that know nothing about us. Perhaps one good starting point could be a series of pulses reflecting some readily recognisable mathematical sequence. Examples are a sequence of square numbers (1,4, 9, 16…) and the Fibonacci sequence (1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13 …). With luck, a clever alien would realise that such sequences are unlikely to arise by chance, and so must be the product of some intelligent being trying to say something. The alien could respond by repeating the sequence and then adding some new sequence.
  • our communication with aliens will have to be in some code that we develop jointly with them. At inter-stellar distances and with no direct observation of our context, it would take aliens a long time (quite possibly forever) to learn a human language. Similarly, we will not be able to learn an alien language.     

Other comments

Some other comments:

  • even if we pick up deliberate messages between aliens and other aliens (of the same species or a different species), we will probably not be able to decode them because we will not be able to make the necessary observations. Thus, it is likely that the only alien messages that we might be able to start decoding are messages directed by aliens to us specifically —or, more likely, directed to the universe at large.
  • although human language is digital, we shouldn’t ignore the possibility that alien communication systems might be analogue.
  • although aliens may (and probably will) differ from us in cognition and conceptual thinking, they may also differ from us physically and physiologically. Those differences may well mould their language.
  • face-to-face meetings with aliens may provide a more promising basis than inter-stellar messages for humans to learn to understand their language and vice versa. But several other issues would arise. I do not discuss those issues here because the likelihood of first contact being face to face seems low.

I will discuss the other 9 chapters in the book in a separate post.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *